Skip to content
Merito
In this section

Buletini v. INS

EB-1AO-1AEB-2 NIWLaw and case law

5 min read

In short

Buletini v. INS, 860 F.Supp. 1222 (E.D. Mich. 1994), is a federal district court decision that the Ninth Circuit mentions in Kazarian v. USCIS. In that parenthetical, the court describes Buletini as finding a denial arbitrary and capricious where an Albanian physician had won a national award, published a medical dictionary and numerous articles, was responsible for general health projects, and served as an adjunct professor. The sources given here say nothing more about the case.

Also known as: Buletini · 860 F.Supp. 1222

Where it applies

  • Buletini v. INS belongs to the extraordinary ability discussion that matters for EB-1A, and Merito also files it under O-1A and EB-2 NIW because readers in those categories meet the same case-law vocabulary. In the source available here, Buletini appears inside the Ninth Circuit's opinion in Kazarian, in a list of decisions that sit beside the statute and the regulation on extraordinary ability.
  • What the sources show is narrow. Kazarian cites Buletini with a short parenthetical and places it next to Matter of Price, a Board of Immigration Appeals decision that granted a petition to a professional golfer. The text of Buletini itself is not among the sources, so this entry describes only what the parenthetical says and does not try to reconstruct the reasoning of the Michigan court.

Why it matters

A reader who sees a case name in a decision, a brief or a commentary can easily treat it as a rule. The Buletini parenthetical is a good reminder to separate two things: what a court found on its own facts, and what a regulation or a precedent requires. The regulation in Kazarian lists a one-time major award or at least three of ten criteria. Buletini is not one of those criteria, and nothing in the source says it changes them.

The parenthetical also shows how courts summarize a person's record: a national award, a published dictionary, numerous articles, health project responsibility and an adjunct post, all in one short line. That compact list can help a reader see what kinds of facts were set out in that case. It does not show how a court weighed them, and it does not describe any other petitioner's record.

How USCIS evaluates it

The case is cited, not applied, in the source

In Kazarian, Buletini appears in a string of citations that illustrate the extraordinary ability context. The source does not say that USCIS adopted Buletini, that officers apply it, or that it sets a test. An officer's task under the regulation quoted in Kazarian is to look at the evidence against a one-time major, internationally recognized award or at least three listed criteria.

What the parenthetical lists

The parenthetical names a national award, a published medical dictionary, numerous articles, responsibility for general health projects and an adjunct professorship. Read against the regulation in Kazarian, some of these resemble listed criteria, such as awards or scholarly articles, while others do not map to a criterion on their face. The sources do not say how the court sorted them, so any mapping is the reader's own reading.

The standard the court applied

The parenthetical says the denial was found arbitrary and capricious. Kazarian explains that a court may set aside agency action only if it is arbitrary, capricious, an abuse of discretion or otherwise not in accordance with law, and that it is an abuse of discretion to act with no evidence to support the decision or on an improper understanding of the law. That is the review vocabulary the phrase belongs to.

Where the burden sits

The USCIS Policy Manual states that the burden of proof to establish eligibility always falls solely on the benefit requestor and never shifts to USCIS. A court decision finding a denial arbitrary does not move that burden. The usual standard in most administrative immigration proceedings is the preponderance of the evidence, meaning the claim is probably true.

A practical example

This is an invented illustration. A reader preparing a brief finds Buletini cited in a commentary and wants to rely on it. Checking the Kazarian opinion, the reader sees only a one-line parenthetical about an Albanian physician and a denial found arbitrary and capricious. The reader therefore keeps the case out of any statement of what the regulation requires, cites the regulation itself for the criteria, and treats Buletini only as a described example whose full text would need to be read before saying more.

A common misconception

One mistaken reading is that Buletini v. INS sets a rule or a checklist for extraordinary ability petitions. The sources show only that Kazarian cites it with a parenthetical about one physician's record and a finding that a denial was arbitrary and capricious; the criteria come from the regulation, and the burden stays on the petitioner.

Common problems

  • Treating a parenthetical as the holding

    A short summary inside another court's opinion compresses a whole decision into one line. A reader who builds an argument on that line has not seen the facts, reasoning or limits of the original case. The sources here do not provide those details.

  • Comparing records without the full text

    Setting a petitioner's award, articles and teaching post beside the Buletini list can look like a comparison. Without the decision itself, the reader cannot tell what weighed in the court's finding, so the comparison rests on a summary, not on the reasoning.

  • Confusing court review with USCIS review

    Arbitrary and capricious is a standard courts use to review agency action, as Kazarian explains. USCIS officers evaluate petitions under the burden and standard of proof described in the Policy Manual. Mixing the two vocabularies blurs who is deciding what.

How to document it

  • The full text of any case you cite

    A parenthetical in another opinion is only a summary. The full decision shows the facts and reasoning that the summary leaves out.

  • The regulation's criteria, quoted from the regulation

    Kazarian reproduces 8 CFR 204.5(h)(3). Citing the regulation directly keeps the criteria tied to their source rather than to a case summary.

  • A table linking each of your own facts to a criterion

    It shows an officer which exhibit supports which criterion, so the record can be followed without relying on any comparison to another person.

  • Evidence behind each award, publication and role

    Documents that show what an award is, where articles appeared and what a role involved give a reader something to check.

Official sources

Use it in Merito

Read your citations with Citation Lens

Last reviewed October 23, 2026

← Back to glossary

Merito is not a law firm and does not offer legal advice or predict approval odds. This is a readiness review to help you and your attorney strengthen your case.