Skip to content
Merito
In this section

Matter of Soffici and Treasure Craft (assertions need documents)

EB-1AO-1AEB-2 NIWLaw and case law

5 min read

In short

Matter of Soffici and Treasure Craft is a decision name used as shorthand for a plain idea: a statement in a petition is not evidence by itself, and it needs documents behind it. This entry explains that idea through the burden and standard of proof, using the listed sources. It does not report the wording of the decision itself.

Also known as: assertions need documents · unsupported statements are not evidence

Where it applies

  • In Merito's classification, this idea belongs to EB-1A, O-1A and EB-2 NIW petitions. In each one the petitioner makes claims: that an award is significant, that a role was leading, that a proposed project matters nationally. The idea concerns how those claims are backed. The Policy Manual chapter on burden speaks of every benefit requestor. The Kazarian and Dhanasar sources show it in an extraordinary ability case and a national interest waiver case.
  • The text of Soffici and Treasure Craft is not among the sources used for this entry, so nothing here states what that decision held. The points below come from the Policy Manual, Kazarian v. USCIS, Matter of Dhanasar and 8 CFR 103.3.

Why it matters

The Policy Manual says the burden of proof to establish eligibility "always falls solely" on the benefit requestor and "never shifts to USCIS." A claim left undocumented is therefore not something an officer is asked to investigate or fill in. The requestor must come forward with facts and evidence that show initial eligibility without any further inquiry.

The usual standard is preponderance of the evidence. Relevant, probative and credible evidence that makes a claim "probably true" meets it. If the requestor falls short, the Manual says it is appropriate for the officer to request more evidence, issue a notice of intent to deny, or deny the case. Dhanasar adds that the quality of evidence counts, not only its quantity. A bare assertion gives an officer little to weigh.

How USCIS evaluates it

Who must supply the proof

Because the burden stays with the requestor, the record is read as what the requestor has actually put forward. A sentence in a cover letter that says an award is prestigious is a claim. The award rules, the selection process and the list of past recipients are documents. The Manual's phrase "without any further inquiry" describes the aim: the file should establish eligibility on its own.

Relevant, probative and credible

The Manual names three qualities of useful evidence: it is relevant to the point claimed, it is probative (it actually helps show the point), and it is credible. Dhanasar repeats relevance, probative value and credibility when it describes the quality of evidence. Each document can be read against these three questions.

Predictions are not facts

The Kazarian opinion records that a colleague wrote that the petitioner's textbook "is certain to be required reading" in many schools. It then notes that the petitioner "presented no evidence" the book was used in any class. The opinion shows the distance between a forecast and a documented fact, and a reader can see that gap in the record.

Written reasons and specific appeals

Under 8 CFR 103.3, an officer who denies a petition must explain the specific reasons in writing. The same regulation says an appeal is summarily dismissed when the party fails to identify specifically any erroneous conclusion of law or statement of fact. Specific statements are expected on both sides of a decision.

A practical example

This is an invented illustration. A researcher states in a personal statement that a software tool she built is widely adopted. An officer reading only that sentence has nothing to check. In a stronger version of the same file, the statement points to download records from the project's repository, a letter from an outside lab describing how it uses the tool, and a published paper that cites it. Each claim now has a document an officer can read and compare.

A common misconception

One mistaken reading is that a detailed, confident account from the petitioner or a supporter can stand in for records. The sources say the burden never shifts to USCIS, and Kazarian shows a predicted use of a book described without any evidence of actual use.

Common problems

  • Praise without a source

    A letter may call work groundbreaking without saying what changed or how the writer knows. The Kazarian opinion sets out reference letters of this general kind next to the observation that no evidence of actual use was presented. A letter that names no source for its claim leaves an officer nothing to check.

  • Claims that outrun the exhibits

    A petition may describe an achievement in strong terms while the attached exhibits show something narrower. Where the documents do not reach the claim, the gap is visible on the page, and an officer may treat the claim as unproven.

  • Appeal grounds stated in general terms

    A brief that says the officer erred but does not identify the erroneous conclusion or statement of fact runs into 8 CFR 103.3(a)(1)(v), which calls for summary dismissal on that ground.

How to document it

  • Primary records for each factual claim

    Contracts, award rules, invitations, repository logs or published pages let an officer see the fact directly instead of relying on someone's description.

  • Letters that name their sources

    A letter that says what the writer saw, when, and how it changed something gives the officer facts to weigh.

  • Independent corroboration

    Media coverage, committee records or outside citations that confirm a claim show it does not rest on the petitioner's word alone. The Dhanasar petitioner paired expert letters with media articles.

  • An exhibit index tied to claims

    A table linking each statement in the cover letter to an exhibit number lets an officer follow the record without searching.

  • Matching details across documents

    Dates, titles and descriptions that agree across the CV, letters and exhibits support credibility.

Official sources

Use it in Merito

Organize your exhibits in the Evidence Binder

Last reviewed October 23, 2026

← Back to glossary

Merito is not a law firm and does not offer legal advice or predict approval odds. This is a readiness review to help you and your attorney strengthen your case.