Skip to content
Merito
In this section

Prior approvals and why they do not bind USCIS

EB-1AO-1AEB-2 NIWThe process

5 min read

In short

A prior approval is an earlier USCIS decision granting a benefit request, either for the same person or for someone else. The regulation ties approval to the evidence submitted with the request being decided, so an earlier grant does not take the place of that evidence. This entry explains why an earlier approval is background and not a rule the next officer must follow.

Also known as: earlier approval · previous approval · approval of a similar case

Where it applies

  • Merito classifies this term under EB-1A, O-1A and EB-2 NIW. The rules quoted here come from the general benefit-request regulations in 8 CFR 103 and from Volume 1 of the USCIS Policy Manual. The sources given do not say these rules are limited to any one category, so this entry presents them as general rules for benefit requests.
  • The term comes up in two ways. In one, a person points to an approval granted to someone else with a similar profile. In the other, the same person has an earlier request that was approved, denied, withdrawn or abandoned, and the new request follows it. The sources treat these differently, so each is kept separate below.

Why it matters

Under 8 CFR 103.2(b)(8)(i), USCIS approves a benefit request when the evidence submitted with it establishes eligibility, and denies it when the record evidence establishes ineligibility. The measure is the record of the request in front of the officer. A person who reads another approval as a promise may build a file around the comparison, not around the documents the regulation looks at.

The Policy Manual describes the same structure. An officer evaluates all evidence submitted, including responses to a Request for Evidence or Notice of Intent to Deny, and approves only if the requestor meets all eligibility requirements. Knowing where an earlier approval fits, and where it does not, helps a reader decide what the file itself must show.

How USCIS evaluates it

The record of the current request

The regulation frames the question as whether the evidence submitted with the benefit request establishes eligibility. If required initial evidence is missing or does not demonstrate eligibility, USCIS may deny the request or ask for the missing evidence. If the initial evidence is complete but does not establish eligibility, USCIS may deny, request more evidence, or issue a notice of intent to deny. Each option is framed around the evidence in this record.

Written reasons in a denial

When an officer denies a petition, 8 CFR 103.3(a)(1)(i) requires the officer to explain the specific reasons in writing. The Policy Manual adds that decisions should use plain language the requestor can understand. A denial therefore shows which findings were made on this record, and it is the document a later appeal or motion responds to.

Precedent decisions are a defined class

Section 103.3(c) describes decisions that the Secretary of Homeland Security, or designated officials, file with the Attorney General for publication as precedent. Once designated, these decisions serve as precedents in all proceedings involving the same issue and are binding on all Service employees, unless modified or overruled by later precedent decisions. The sources give this binding effect to published precedent decisions. They do not extend it to an individual approval notice.

A practical example

This is an invented illustration. A consultant hears that a colleague with a similar job title received an approval notice. The consultant's file spends a page describing the colleague's case but includes only two exhibits about the consultant's own work. Under 8 CFR 103.2(b)(8), the officer decides whether the evidence submitted with this request establishes eligibility. A version of the file that places the consultant's own documents first, each tied to a requirement, gives the officer the material the regulation points to. The colleague's approval, if mentioned at all, is background.

A common misconception

One mistaken reading is that an approval for a similar person, or for an earlier request, sets a standard USCIS must follow in the next case. The sources instead say each request is decided on the evidence submitted with it, and they describe binding effect for decisions designated and published as precedent under 8 CFR 103.3(c).

Common problems

  • Treating an approval notice as a precedent decision

    Section 103.3(c) describes precedent decisions as designated by the Secretary or designated officials and published for the public. A notice granting one person's request is not described there as designated or published. Presenting it as if it carried the force of a precedent decision blurs a distinction the regulation draws.

  • Assuming an approval can never be revisited

    The fee provision in 8 CFR 103.2(b)(1) says an approval may be revoked upon notice if USCIS later determines the correct fee was not paid. A reader who treats any approval as closed for all purposes overlooks that the regulation provides for revocation in at least this situation.

  • Expecting an abandoned or withdrawn request to carry forward

    Under 8 CFR 103.2(b)(15), the priority or processing date of a withdrawn or abandoned request may not be applied to a later one. The earlier facts are material to the new request, so a new filing is read alongside what happened before, not as a continuation.

How to document it

  • The current person's own evidence, organized by requirement

    Each exhibit shows a fact about this person, and the regulation looks to the evidence submitted with the request to establish eligibility.

  • Copies of the person's own earlier notices

    An approval, denial, withdrawal acknowledgement or abandonment notice for the same person shows what was decided and when, which matters because earlier facts are material to a new request.

  • The written reasons from any earlier denial

    Section 103.3(a)(1)(i) requires specific reasons in writing, so the denial shows what the officer found on that record.

  • A full citation for any precedent decision relied on

    Section 103.3(c) gives binding effect to designated decisions published as precedent, so a citation lets a reader confirm the decision is one of those.

Official sources

Use it in Merito

Read your case the way an officer would

Last reviewed October 23, 2026

← Back to glossary

Merito is not a law firm and does not offer legal advice or predict approval odds. This is a readiness review to help you and your attorney strengthen your case.