Skip to content
Merito
← Back to results
EB-1AHealthcare, clinicalIndividualDecided 2013Dismissed

Outcome: Dismissed

FEB112013_01B2203

JudgingMetAwardsNot metScholarly articlesNot metLeading or critical roleClaimed, not analyzedMembershipClaimed, not analyzedOriginal contributionsClaimed, not analyzedFinal meritsNot met

Our summary

A geriatric physician self-petitioner claimed EB-1A extraordinary ability. The petitioner established one criterion (judging) but failed on awards and scholarly articles. The AAO affirmed dismissal, finding insufficient evidence of sustained national or international acclaim or place among the very top of the field.

Official PDF

Official PDF ↗

Published by USCIS. The summary is ours, in our own words; the decision text is on uscis.gov.

What the AAO accepted

  • Judging · Director found petitioner met criterion; AAO affirmed

What was missing

  • Awards · Awards were local or nominations only, not nationally or internationally recognized
  • Scholarly articles · Abstracts do not qualify as scholarly articles; lack of professional or major publications
  • Final merits · Evidence does not establish sustained national or international acclaim or top rank in geriatric medicine

Criteria

CriterionReadingWhy
JudgingMetDirector found petitioner met criterion; AAO affirmed
AwardsNot metAwards were local or nominations only, not nationally or internationally recognized
Scholarly articlesNot metAbstracts do not qualify as scholarly articles; lack of professional or major publications
Leading or critical roleClaimed, not analyzedCriterion discussed but not fully analyzed regarding organizations claimed
MembershipClaimed, not analyzedClaimed but not analyzed; petitioner abandoned claim on appeal
Original contributionsClaimed, not analyzedClaimed but petitioner abandoned specific challenge on appeal
Final meritsNot metEvidence does not establish sustained national or international acclaim or top rank in geriatric medicine

A published decision describes one case. It is not legal advice and not a prediction for yours.

Similar decisions

Decisions whose text is closest to this one.