Musician and musical director filed EB-1A petition claiming extraordinary ability. Petitioner met only two of ten required criteria. AAO found regional success and upward career trajectory but insufficient evidence of sustained national or international acclaim at very top of field. Appeal dismissed.

A musician sought EB-1A extraordinary ability classification. The petitioner claimed multiple criteria including awards, membership, published material, and others. The AAO found only two criteria met, below the required three-criterion threshold, and concluded the evidence does not demonstrate sustained national or international acclaim or placement in the small percentage at the top.

A violinist sought EB-1A classification based on awards and achievements. The AAO found finalist selections, scholarships, and student competition awards insufficient; they do not evidence nationally or internationally recognized prizes for artists of all levels, only early-career musicians.

Musician and teacher in China seeking EB-1A. Initially approved then revoked. Claimed awards and association memberships as musician and teacher. AAO found award shared among 53 recipients and memberships based on activity and dues rather than outstanding achievement. Overall evidence does not demonstrate sustained international acclaim at the very top.