Outcome: Dismissed
MAR302026_01B2203
Our summary
ESL instructor claimed extraordinary ability under EB-1A. Met judging criterion only. Membership and leading role criteria rejected; published material and original contributions waived on appeal; high salary reserved. Petitioner failed three-criterion threshold, so final merits not analyzed.
Official PDF
Official PDF ↗Published by USCIS. The summary is ours, in our own words; the decision text is on uscis.gov.
What the AAO accepted
- Judging · SCOPS determined petitioner fulfilled judging criterion, finding not disturbed by AAO.
What was missing
- Leading or critical role · Petitioner did not establish that ESL instructor and curriculum team role was leading or critical for employer; recommendation letters focused on typical duties.
- Membership · Curriculum support team membership does not require outstanding achievements judged by recognized national or international experts in the field.
Criteria
| Criterion | Reading | Why |
|---|---|---|
| Met | SCOPS determined petitioner fulfilled judging criterion, finding not disturbed by AAO. | |
| Not met | Petitioner did not establish that ESL instructor and curriculum team role was leading or critical for employer; recommendation letters focused on typical duties. | |
| Not met | Curriculum support team membership does not require outstanding achievements judged by recognized national or international experts in the field. | |
| Claimed, not analyzed | Claimed initially but waived on appeal; not analyzed. | |
| Claimed, not analyzed | Claimed initially but waived on appeal; not analyzed. | |
| Not reached / not discussed | Not reached; petitioner failed to meet three-criterion evidentiary threshold. |
A published decision describes one case. It is not legal advice and not a prediction for yours.
