Published AAO appeal decisions

Self-petitioner claimed extraordinary ability in international travel logistics and management. AAO upheld denial finding petitioner did not satisfy membership criterion (employment is not association membership), leading critical role criterion (required plural organizations with distinguished reputation), or overall extraordinary ability standard.

Construction professional claimed extraordinary ability in international construction economics. AAO upheld denial, finding petitioner failed to meet awards and membership criteria because evidence showed employer company recognition, not individual petitioner achievement or membership.

Professional claiming extraordinary ability through membership in associations, published material, and leading role criteria. AAO found rotary club involvement does not meet membership requirement and counsel abandoned other claims. Dismissed for failure to satisfy three criteria.

Self-petitioner sought extraordinary ability in business for beneficiary but failed to demonstrate major award or three regulatory criteria. Appeal statement merely asserted documents prove eligibility without identifying specific director errors or substantively addressing evidence. Appeal dismissed.