Published AAO appeal decisions

Project manager petitioner claimed extraordinary ability based on professional certifications and program completion. AAO found petitioner failed to establish membership in qualifying associations and did not demonstrate sustained national or international acclaim or extraordinary achievement in the field.

A business and education professional sought EB-1A extraordinary ability classification. The petitioner claimed membership in a professional association and submitted evidence on one criterion. The AAO dismissed the appeal, finding the petitioner did not establish membership requirement or that evidence demonstrated exceptional national or international acclaim necessary for the category.

A business person sought EB-1A classification submitting evidence of awards, Rotary Club membership, and publication contributions. The AAO rejected each criterion: missing documentation, undemonstrated membership requirements, and unqualifying publication evidence. Final merits assessment found insufficient sustained acclaim.

Economic and political consultant claiming extraordinary ability under EB-1A. Petitioner submitted evidence of awards and association memberships but failed to establish they met regulatory criteria. Awards were not nationally or internationally recognized; memberships lacked evidence of outstanding achievement requirements. AAO dismissed appeal for insufficient extraordinary ability.