Published AAO appeal decisions

Legal consultant in alternative dispute resolution sought EB-2 with national interest waiver. Proposed establishing consultancy for ADR and public bond investment. AAO dismissed, finding the specific endeavor lacked demonstrated national importance; petitioner confused field importance with endeavor-specific impact and failed to show broader implications.

A chemist and postdoctoral researcher sought EB-2 national interest waiver for research on high-performance materials for energy conversion. The AAO found the proposed endeavor met the first Dhanasar prong but the petitioner was not well positioned to advance it due to lack of demonstrated success and institutional support. The appeal was dismissed.

A research scientist with a master's degree in electrical and computer engineering sought an NIW for EB-2 classification. The AAO found the proposed endeavor had substantial merit and national importance but dismissed because the petitioner lacked a concrete plan and employment pursuit evidence to demonstrate he was well-positioned to advance it.

A civil engineer with a master's degree sought EB-2 classification with a national interest waiver for an AI-based construction software tool. The AAO found the petitioner qualified for EB-2 and established substantial merit but dismissed the appeal because the petitioner failed to demonstrate the national importance required by Dhanasar's first prong.

Civil engineer proposing to found consulting services company in Massachusetts. Failed first Dhanasar prong on national importance; generic consulting for construction companies lacked national or global implications. Business plan contained numerous errors and unreliable financial projections. Appeal dismissed.

Biofuels engineer with advanced degree sought waiver based on proposed ethanol production and export optimization. AAO affirmed SCOPS finding that endeavor lacked national importance, being limited to employer and partners without demonstrated broader impact on ethanol industry or economy. Appeal dismissed.

Petitioner with advanced degree sought EB-2 NIW for project management consultancy using AI optimization. AAO dismissed appeal, finding substantial merit but not national importance. Petitioner conflated industry importance with endeavor-specific prospective impact and failed to demonstrate broader implications beyond her business.

A consultant engineer with 28 years experience sought EB-2 NIW for affordable housing and resilience engineering work. SCOPS approved advanced degree qualification but denied NIW. The AAO affirmed dismissal, finding the proposed endeavor, though in important industry, lacked demonstrated national importance as required by Dhanasar's first prong.

An IT systems engineer seeking EB-2 classification with a national interest waiver filed a self-petition. The AAO found the beneficiary qualified for EB-2 as an advanced degree professional but failed to establish national importance of his proposed endeavor. The vague business plan lacked evidence of significant employment creation or economic benefits at regional or national levels.

AI engineer self-petitioner sought NIW based on broad plans to advance AI and exponential technologies for healthcare and general use. AAO found no specific proposed endeavor: petitioner discussed general intentions without particularizing data-driven tools, efficiency gains, or LLM inference work. Appeal dismissed; favorable prong determinations withdrawn without specific endeavor.

An aircraft mechanic sought EB-2 classification with a national interest waiver to develop aviation maintenance training programs. SCOPS found the endeavor had substantial merit but the AAO affirmed dismissal, holding the petitioner failed to establish national importance because the record lacked specifics on prospective impact and the expert letter addressed industry importance rather than the specific proposed endeavor's impact.

Consultant with advanced degree proposing consulting and auditing services for small and medium businesses in financial compliance and governance. AAO held working in important industry insufficient; specific endeavor lacks demonstrated broader implications for field or economy.

Materials engineer seeking EB-2 with national interest waiver for supply chain optimization initiative. Petitioner holds advanced degree but failed to establish national importance of proposed endeavor; claimed scalability and broad impacts lack specific details and independent corroborating evidence.

Research engineer seeks NIW under EB-2 to conduct research in vehicle safety, renewable energy, and data centers. AAO dismissed, finding substantial merit but insufficient evidence of national importance; research activities limited to employer and clients without demonstrated broader implications.

IT consultant sought EB-2 with national interest waiver claiming exceptional ability. AAO affirmed second denial after remand, finding only one of six exceptional ability criteria met. National importance not established for proposed IT consulting endeavor.

A supply and trade professional sought EB-2 with national interest waiver for maritime logistics work. The AAO dismissed the appeal, finding his proposed endeavor lacked sufficient specificity regarding actual activities and failed to demonstrate national importance or broader implications beyond generalized objectives.

Entrepreneur self-petitioner sought NIW for medical billing and revenue cycle management business. SCOPS found substantial merit but not national importance. Petitioner appealed with only generalized error statements without developing arguments for any Dhanasar prong. Appeal dismissed for waived arguments and failure to meet burden.

Senior engineering program manager with advanced degree seeks NIW for research on electromechanical systems including motor design, hybrid vehicle powertrains, and aerospace monitoring. SCOPS approved advanced degree qualification and substantial merit but denied national importance. AAO upheld dismissal, finding insufficient evidence of broader field impact or economic effects rising to national importance.

A mechanical engineer sought a national interest waiver for an EB-2 employment-based petition. The AAO dismissed the appeal, finding the petitioner failed to establish that the proposed thermal management research endeavor has national importance, the first Dhanasar prong required for waiver eligibility.

A statistician with an approved labor certification sought a national interest waiver to develop statistical methods for biomedical discovery and clinical trials. The AAO dismissed the appeal, holding expert letters lacked persuasive corroborating evidence that his specific proposed endeavor would achieve national importance in biomedical science.

Computer science PhD studying efficient AI model deployment met first Dhanasar prong on substantial merit and national importance. However, AAO found insufficient evidence of being well positioned to advance the proposed endeavor through citations, letters, and research record. Third prong not reached. Appeal dismissed.

An employer petitions for a financial investor to receive an NIW for consulting services promoting U.S. business investment in China. The AAO found substantial merit but rejected national importance, concluding projected revenue, tax contributions, and job creation lacked evidence of broader regional or national economic impact.

Pharmacist sought EB-2 with national interest waiver claiming exceptional ability. AAO affirmed denial, finding although three criteria were met, evidence did not establish expertise significantly above ordinary levels in pharmaceutical services. NIW prongs reserved as unnecessary.

An entrepreneur seeking EB-2 national interest waiver proposed developing zeolite-based fertilizers, filters, and supplements for agriculture and energy sectors. AAO dismissed the appeal, finding insufficient evidence that his specific endeavor would have national importance or broad field impact beyond promotional materials and general letters.

Industrial engineer seeking EB-2 with national interest waiver for modular oil and gas facility modernization work. Petitioner claimed national economic and environmental benefits. AAO held proposed endeavor lacked sufficient direct evidentiary tie to claimed benefits and national importance.