Published AAO appeal decisions

Visual artist claiming extraordinary ability in visual arts. Submitted organizational prize and television interview. AAO found prize not nationally or internationally recognized, television appearance does not constitute published material, and exhibition evidence lacked specific dates. Appeal dismissed.

Community outreach liaison showcasing Filipino artists' performances seeking EB-1A. Claimed awards, published material, exhibitions criteria. AAO rejected all three: awards were collective, publications not about petitioner, exhibitions criterion for visual artists. Appeal dismissed.

A music composer and arranger sought EB-1A classification without submitting initial evidence. On appeal, the petitioner submitted letters, diplomas, an award for cantorial preservation, and compact disc materials. The AAO found none met regulatory criteria: the award was not nationally recognized, and recordings lacked evidence of commercial success as required by regulation.

A petitioner in the media and visual arts seeks EB-1A extraordinary ability. Claimed multiple criteria including awards and published material. AAO found awards not nationally recognized and limited to students, published material lacking, and overall evidence insufficient to show sustained acclaim at top level.