Skip to content
Merito
← Back to results
EB-1AArts, design, architectureIndividualDecided May 2020Dismissed

Outcome: Dismissed

MAY292020_09B2203

JudgingMetAwardsNot metPublished materialNot metFinal meritsNot met

Our summary

Pianist sought EB-1A classification. Claimed awards, published material, and judging. AAO found only judging criterion met; awards lacked national recognition and publications were not in recognized trade outlets. Appeal dismissed because insufficient criteria satisfied and no evidence of sustained acclaim.

Official PDF

Official PDF ↗

Published by USCIS. The summary is ours, in our own words; the decision text is on uscis.gov.

What the AAO accepted

  • Judging · Petitioner judged student musical competition

What was missing

  • Awards · Prizes lacked national or international recognition; limited age requirements and minor prize money not characteristic of elite awards
  • Published material · Articles in Music Review and Music Journal not established as professional or major trade publications
  • Final merits · Insufficient evidence of sustained national or international acclaim or place among top percentage in field

Criteria

CriterionReadingWhy
JudgingMetPetitioner judged student musical competition
AwardsNot metPrizes lacked national or international recognition; limited age requirements and minor prize money not characteristic of elite awards
Published materialNot metArticles in Music Review and Music Journal not established as professional or major trade publications
Final meritsNot metInsufficient evidence of sustained national or international acclaim or place among top percentage in field

A published decision describes one case. It is not legal advice and not a prediction for yours.

Similar decisions

Decisions whose text is closest to this one.