Chinese artist appealed EB-1A denial claiming memberships in folk artist associations. AAO summarily dismissed for failure to respond meaningfully to RFE, submitting required membership criteria documentation late, and providing arguments addressing only one of ten required criteria.

Folk artist petitioner claimed extraordinary ability. Petitioner failed to submit evidence addressing regulatory criteria and did not respond adequately to director's request for documentation. AAO summarily dismissed appeal for lack of substantive arguments and insufficient evidence.

Professional in unspecified field claimed extraordinary ability with recognized reputation. Petitioner submitted no brief, arguments, or additional evidence on appeal and declined separate submission. AAO summarily dismissed for failure to identify erroneous conclusions or present substantive arguments.

A self-represented petitioner sought extraordinary ability classification after the director found no sustained national or international acclaim. On appeal the petitioner offered only a general statement about reputation and a request for reconsideration, with no argument or evidence. The AAO summarily dismissed the appeal for failing to identify any specific error.