Published AAO appeal decisions

Microbiologist self-petitioner sought NIW under EB-2. AAO found first prong met and withdrew SCOPS adverse finding, but dismissed on second prong, holding PhD and citation numbers alone insufficient to show she is well-positioned to advance the proposed microbiological research endeavor.

A researcher in earthquake science and seismic monitoring sought a national interest waiver of the job offer requirement under the Dhanasar framework. The AAO accepted substantial merit but held the proposed endeavor lacked demonstrated national importance, since broader field benefits and federal priorities did not show his own work's impact. It dismissed the appeal.

Ecologist with PhD seeking EB-2 NIW for climate change research on carbon cycling and greenhouse gas emissions. Claimed endeavor has national importance through field relevance and expert letters. AAO held proposed specific endeavor lacks national importance; evidence addresses field importance rather than prospective impact of particular work.

Graduate student in international law sought EB-2 NIW for online platform expanding African student pathways to U.S. education. AAO dismissed appeal, finding the specific endeavor lacks national importance; modest projected hiring and revenue insufficient for substantial economic impact.

A postdoctoral researcher in geological sciences with Ph.D. sought NIW for AI-enabled subsurface prediction framework for carbon capture. AAO dismissed because the applicant failed to demonstrate the specific proposed endeavor has national importance; general field importance and employer benefits insufficient without showing broader prospective impact.

CEO and entrepreneur in healthcare facility maintenance and waste management seeks to establish cleaning services business in Florida. Claimed endeavor would strengthen healthcare institutions and create jobs. AAO dismissed appeal; AAO also withdrew USCIS determination that petitioner qualifies as advanced degree professional, and found endeavor lacks national importance.

Advanced degree professional in Islamic banking and finance seeking national interest waiver. Proposed ethical-finance toolkit for multistate adoption. USCIS and AAO found endeavor meritorious but lacked corroborating evidence of substantial economic effects, field-broad impact, or national importance required under Dhanasar framework.

Training and development specialist sought EB-2 NIW for workforce training endeavor. USCIS found substantial merit but denied, concluding proposed endeavor lacked national importance. AAO dismissed, finding petitioner failed to demonstrate specific endeavor would have broader implications or substantial prospective impact beyond personal business.

Enterprise account engineer sought national interest waiver under EB-2, proposing consulting services to SMEs for cloud migration and cybersecurity modernization. AAO found endeavor lacked sufficient evidence of prospective national importance, focusing on her individual consulting work rather than field-wide or broader economic impact.

Musician and music teacher seeks NIW for EB-2 to establish national network of rhythm therapy centers. USCIS found substantial merit but AAO affirmed no national importance shown; petitioner not well-positioned to advance without evidence of scalable model implementation.

An aircraft technician seeks EB-2 NIW based on exceptional ability and national interest waiver. AAO found the proposed endeavor has substantial merit but lacks national importance. Although the petitioner cited aviation safety and training programs, he did not demonstrate how his specific work or training would produce broad impacts or substantial economic effects at national scale.

A physician seeking EB-2 classification with NIW claimed his proposed endeavor merits waiver of job offer requirement. The AAO held the endeavor lacks sufficient national importance under Dhanasar because it relies on alignment with government priorities rather than demonstrating specific, prospective national impact.

Chemical engineer seeking EB-2 NIW to start U.S. consulting company. Claimed extensive petrochemical industry experience and customer interest demonstrate national importance and economic impact. AAO held specific proposed endeavor lacks national importance; prior work experience and customer letters relate to second prong, not national importance of proposed venture itself.

A power electronics researcher sought EB-2 classification with national interest waiver. The AAO dismissed the appeal because the petitioner failed to define a specific proposed endeavor, instead providing only broad aspirational statements about developing experimental setups for semiconductors, making all three Dhanasar prongs unadjustable.

An aviation pilot and entrepreneur sought NIW to develop flight planning software for general aviation. The AAO dismissed the appeal, finding insufficient evidence of national importance; the proposed endeavor's benefits appeared limited to the petitioner's startup without demonstrating broader impacts on the aviation industry or economy.

Business owner sought NIW to produce non-GMO fruit preserves. Qualified for underlying EB-2 advanced degree classification. AAO dismissed appeal because petitioner failed to demonstrate endeavor has national importance independent of alignment with governmental agricultural priorities; small local operation with fifteen projected employees lacked demonstrable broader economic or industry impact.

A computer scientist with a Ph.D. in computer science seeks EB-2 with NIW. The AAO dismissed the appeal, finding she misunderstood national importance requirements and failed to show her proposed endeavor would impact the field broadly. Routine or incremental contributions without broader implications do not satisfy the Dhanasar standard.

Cybersecurity professional with master's degree sought EB-2 NIW for developing post-quantum cryptography toolkits for small and medium institutions. AAO found endeavor lacked demonstrated national importance: proposed work and supporting evidence did not establish prospective impact, funding plan, timeline, or scale of utilization commensurate with national benefit.

A drilling engineer with an advanced degree sought an EB-2 national interest waiver for a predictive maintenance project. The AAO found the endeavor has substantial merit but lacks demonstrated national importance beyond the employer and immediate business partners, failing the first Dhanasar prong. The appeal was dismissed without reaching the second and third prongs.

A banking executive with a master's degree in monetary banking and three decades in finance proposed to develop a fintech platform providing replicable credit infrastructure to small and medium-sized enterprises. The AAO dismissed the appeal, finding the endeavor addresses nationwide problems but lacks demonstrated field-wide impact required for national importance.

Lawyer and entrepreneur sought EB-2 NIW to establish firm facilitating Brazilian-U.S. business connections. AAO held proposed endeavor lacked national importance under Dhanasar's first prong because beneficiary showed insufficient broader field impact and inadequate projections demonstrating substantial economic benefits.

A systems engineer sought an NIW but failed to demonstrate national importance for his endeavor. The AAO found his business plans and impact claims too general and localized; assertions about secondary ripple effects and industry alignment did not satisfy Dhanasar's requirement for substantial positive economic effects or broad field advancement.

A designer of mathematical education programs with EB-2 advanced degree sought NIW. AAO affirmed denial, finding the proposed endeavor had substantial merit but petitioner failed to demonstrate significant potential to employ U.S. workers or generate substantial economic benefits required for national importance.

Petitioner is a cybersecurity professional proposing to advance Internet of Things security in critical infrastructure. The AAO dismissed the appeal finding substantial merit but lacking national importance; petitioner's skills and client-focused work do not demonstrate broader implications rising to national importance level required.

Advanced degree professional proposed financial workflow optimization for small and medium enterprises. AAO dismissed appeal because proposed endeavor lacked national importance; evidence of industry importance insufficient to establish specific endeavor's national significance under Dhanasar framework.