Published AAO appeal decisions

An industrial production management consultant self-petitioning for EB-2 NIW sought to establish a consulting business providing operational efficiency services. The AAO affirmed denial because the proposed endeavor lacked demonstrated national importance beyond local business impacts and employment projections, failing the first Dhanasar prong.

CEO of automobile detailing and product retail company claims NIW for business expansion to New Jersey and California. AAO held endeavor lacks national importance; vague expansion plans without specific locations prevent establishing significant employment or economic effects.

HR manager and entrepreneur sought EB-2 NIW to establish consulting firm. AAO found she lacked advanced degree equivalency and that her proposed endeavor, though having substantial merit, failed to demonstrate national importance because it would not impact the HR field broadly or generate substantial economic effects beyond her future clients.

An entrepreneur and training specialist sought an NIW after obtaining an advanced degree. The appeal was dismissed as moot because the petitioner obtained permanent resident status through an approved petition before the AAO decision.

A business executive petitioned for EB-1A extraordinary ability status based on nine claimed criteria, including awards, membership, and high salary. The AAO found no major award and rejected lesser prizes and membership as nationally or internationally recognized. High salary finding was withdrawn due to insufficient documentation. The petitioner did not meet the initial three-criterion threshold and lacks sustained national or international acclaim.

Market researcher sought EB-2 NIW, claiming proposed market research endeavor would benefit industry and public via peer-reviewed publications. AAO found no evidence of national importance; the endeavor's effects would be confined to employer and clients, lacking broader implications required by Dhanasar.

A Canadian business manager and entrepreneur seeks EB-1A extraordinary ability classification. The AAO dismissed the appeal, finding the petitioner met zero evidentiary criteria required for extraordinary ability and lacked sustained national or international acclaim as required by statute.

HR director seeking NIW for small business startup. Petitioner reargued previous positions on national importance without new facts or legal errors. AAO dismissed third motion to reconsider, finding evidence of business plan, expert opinion, and client letters already analyzed and found insufficient.

Administrative services and facilities manager sought EB-1A extraordinary ability classification. AAO dismissed because petitioner failed to meet the minimum three of ten evidentiary criteria. Awards and membership criteria were not met; artistic exhibition criterion inapplicable to administrative work; record did not demonstrate sustained national or international acclaim.

A logistician sought EB-1A classification claiming four evidentiary criteria. The AAO affirmed dismissal, finding the petitioner failed to document individual association membership and lacked evidence of judging others' work in logistics. Meeting only two of ten required criteria precluded reaching final merits analysis.

A CEO of a healthcare consulting firm sought EB-2 NIW classification. The AAO found her proposed endeavor addressing rural healthcare access lacked national importance because she did not demonstrate how it would impact her field broadly beyond individual clients, and past achievements do not establish endeavor importance under Dhanasar.

A swimming pool company executive with a master's degree in linguistic sciences sought EB-2 NIW classification. The petitioner's proposed endeavor was operating a swimming pool company. The AAO affirmed that work benefiting a single employer and its clients lacks national importance without demonstrating broader field implications or substantial economic effects.

A general and operations manager sought EB-1A extraordinary ability classification. SCOPS required evidence of intent to continue work in the field and national benefit; the petitioner did not respond to these concerns on appeal. The AAO dismissed based on waiver of the two dispositive statutory requirements.

Human resources management consultant proposed consulting business targeting oil and gas sector. Petitioner established substantial merit but failed to demonstrate national importance; evidence emphasized industry importance rather than specific impact of proposed endeavor beyond unidentified clients.

Construction manager and entrepreneur sought EB-2 NIW classification. AAO affirmed denial, finding petitioner did not establish exceptional ability or meet sufficient evidentiary criteria. National interest waiver issue not addressed because petitioner ineligible for underlying classification.

A social and community service manager and entrepreneur sought EB-2 NIW classification. The AAO dismissed the appeal, finding the petitioner failed to establish that her proposed endeavor had national importance under Dhanasar's first prong, focusing on broader prospective impact rather than industry or profession importance.

Contact center entrepreneur seeks NIW to operate call center service provider. AAO dismissed appeal, finding petitioner did not establish national importance of proposed endeavor. While services may benefit government clients, they lack innovation or evidence of broader industry impact or economic significance beyond company and direct clients.

A sales specialist and trainer claiming extraordinary ability under EB-1A sought to satisfy four criteria: published material, original contributions, leading role, and high salary. The AAO affirmed dismissal, finding published material and original contributions unsubstantiated and insufficient to meet the three-criterion minimum.

Logistics management consultant seeking EB-2 NIW for supply chain and trade consulting work. AAO dismissed appeal; petitioner failed to demonstrate national importance despite claims about supply chain resilience and Brazil trade relations, as projections showed only 15 employees versus industry baseline of 13.3 million.

A chief executive officer selling Italian furniture sought EB-1A extraordinary ability classification. The AAO held the petitioner failed to establish three required criteria: published material lacked proper documentation, judging of manufacturers was not in an allied field, original business contributions lacked demonstrated major significance, and scholarly articles were not authored by petitioner.

An employer petitioned for an EB-2 national interest waiver for a strategic project manager. The AAO found the petitioner was not qualified as an advanced degree professional due to insufficient undergraduate credentials, and the proposed endeavor lacked demonstrated national importance beyond the specific business and its clients. Appeal dismissed.

Business management and marketing specialist with master's degree in MBA sought EB-2 NIW for substance abuse prevention consulting company. SCOPS approved advanced degree qualification. AAO found services did not extend beyond individual clients to impact field broadly, lacked innovation, and insufficient job creation or economic benefit.

Advanced degree professional seeks NIW for business endeavor supporting small and medium-sized enterprises. Claimed alignment with U.S. government initiatives and economic benefits would establish national importance. AAO found vague assertions without specific details or probative evidence of broader industry impact; merely working in important field insufficient without demonstrating specific endeavor's national importance.

Information technology project manager claimed extraordinary ability in business. AAO affirmed denial because petitioner failed to meet three of ten criteria and showed no major award; lacks sustained acclaim or recognition consistent with top of field.

Entrepreneur and financial expert sought EB-2 NIW for business valuation and marketing venture. AAO held proposed endeavor, though addressing retirement and economic growth, lacks national importance; unsupported assertions and lack of specific prospective impact failed Dhanasar prong one.