Published AAO appeal decisions

Graphic designer seeks NIW classification. Proposed multiple inconsistent endeavors including consulting, training, nonprofit work, and design roles. AAO found petitioner shifted plans and failed to provide consistent, coherent, specific description supported by independent evidence. Appeal dismissed.

Chemical engineering graduate student seeks NIW for research designing materials for PFAS water purification. AAO found first prong met but rejected second prong, concluding citations and publications alone insufficient to show field influence and well-positioning.

A systems engineer sought a national interest waiver for EB-2 classification. The AAO dismissed, finding the petitioner failed to establish the national importance of the proposed consulting endeavor under the first Dhanasar prong, with broad claims and formulaic support letters lacking credibility.

Pilot sought EB-2 national interest waiver for aviation training endeavor. AAO found proposed work has substantial merit but lacks national importance under Dhanasar's first prong. Letters of support insufficient; no evidence of broader industry impact or substantial positive economic effects. Second and third prongs not reached.

An internal medicine resident with advanced degree sought EB-2 NIW for interventional cardiology research. The AAO found the proposed research had substantial merit and national importance under the first Dhanasar prong. However, the second prong failed because letters of support lacked specific examples of how the petitioner's work affected clinical practice or demonstrated sufficient success warranting waiver of labor certification.

Commercial bank manager with 30 years experience sought EB-2 NIW classification under Dhanasar framework. AAO affirmed that proposed endeavor, though substantially meritorious, lacked national importance. Evidence showed company sales projections and job creation at 16 employees but failed to demonstrate substantial positive economic effects at national level required by Dhanasar.

Advanced degree professional in aviation safety sought NIW for endeavor providing safety training and consultancy to airlines. AAO found no demonstrated national importance: articles on aviation safety importance insufficient; petitioner failed to show specific endeavor methods would have national implications or create substantial U.S. economic impact. Appeal dismissed.

Management analyst with advanced degree sought EB-2 national interest waiver for endeavor improving financial services in underserved areas. AAO found substantial merit but insufficient national importance; impact was not shown to extend broadly to industry level, so dismissed the appeal.

An attorney proposed work as a professional mediator through her own company. The AAO dismissed the appeal, holding the applicant failed the first prong because individual mediation services lacked national importance; she provided no expert evidence showing field-wide impact or connection to national initiatives.

A public health specialist seeking EB-2 national interest waiver proposed tuberculosis control research and care optimization in California. The AAO dismissed the appeal, finding the petitioner established substantial merit but failed to demonstrate national importance because proposed work involves localized patient care without broader field-wide implications.

A mechanical engineer with Ph.D. equivalent seeks EB-2 national interest waiver for research improving fault diagnosis and predictive maintenance in heavy machinery. The AAO dismissed because the petitioner demonstrated substantial merit but failed to establish national importance, submitting only general background articles without sufficient evidence of prospective national-level impact.

A business administrator sought EB-2 classification as advanced degree professional or person of exceptional ability, plus NIW. SCOPS denied both. The AAO remanded, finding SCOPS misrepresented the record, confused two separate petitions, and did not provide meaningful opportunity to contest. No opinion on ultimate merits.

A self-petitioning business owner sought a national interest waiver with EB-2 classification. After the denial, appeal and earlier motions were dismissed, she filed a motion to reopen. The AAO dismissed it because it offered no new facts backed by documents addressing the prior dismissal, and the merits of the waiver were not reached.

Entrepreneur in teambuilding and business development sought EB-2 NIW to establish consulting firm. AAO found endeavor had substantial merit but lacked national importance. Petitioner failed to demonstrate prospective impact extending beyond individual consulting services to show substantial economic effects or broader field implications.

Computer security researcher sought EB-2 NIW to continue research on software security tools for consumer devices and services. AAO found endeavor has substantial merit but not national importance; evidence focused on petitioner's qualifications and field importance rather than proposed endeavor's prospective impact beyond employer.

AI researcher sought EB-2 NIW classification claiming exceptional ability. AAO dismissed appeal, finding petitioner met only two of three required criteria for exceptional ability: official academic record and professional association membership, but not recognition for achievements and significant contributions in AI field.

Mining engineer sought EB-2 with national interest waiver to improve domestic mining of critical minerals through block-cave mining expertise. AAO dismissed, finding the proposed endeavor lacked national importance because evidence only demonstrated importance of the critical minerals field itself and benefits to individual companies, not broader implications for the mining industry.

An electrical engineer sought NIW for work in renewable solar energy. AAO agreed with USCIS that the proposed endeavor has substantial merit but lacks national importance under Dhanasar's first prong. Petitioner failed to demonstrate specific methodologies, unique advances, or prospective impact beyond his employer. Appeal dismissed without reaching remaining Dhanasar prongs.

A financial director and entrepreneur with an advanced degree in finance sought NIW for work as finance director at a used car dealership. The AAO found her original endeavor lacked substantial merit and national importance due to vague descriptions and generic claims about economic benefits without specific, prospective impact evidence.

An electrical engineer with an advanced degree sought NIW for employment-based second preference. The AAO dismissed the appeal, holding that her proposed research in GaN-based power electronics for EV charging lacked the requisite national importance under Dhanasar; benefits to specific employers and vague assertions of potential impact were insufficient.

Biomechanical engineer and researcher claiming NIW for EB-2 with proposed endeavor in cell therapy and biomaterials. Substantial merit found but national importance not established; prospective impact not attributed to petitioner or shown to have prospective economic effect. Appeal dismissed.

Petitioner with advanced degree sought EB-2 NIW classification for homecare business. The petitioner demonstrated substantial merit but failed to establish national importance under Dhanasar. The AAO found the business lacked evidence of substantial positive economic effects or broader field impact beyond limited client and employee benefits, declining to analyze the remaining NIW prongs.

An entomology professor with a Ph.D. in medical entomology seeks an EB-2 national interest waiver for research on German cockroach insecticide resistance. AAO held the proposed endeavor lacks the specific detail, novelty, and documented potential for broad impact required to establish national importance under Dhanasar's first prong.

Dog food chef and luxury pet boutique co-owner sought EB-2 national interest waiver. AAO affirmed USCIS denial, finding petitioner's dog food business lacks national importance despite business awards and customer letters. Business does not extend beyond its clients to impact broader economy, industry, or American public welfare.

Labor relations expert and entrepreneur seeks EB-2 with national interest waiver for consulting firm. AAO found substantial merit but no national importance because impact limited to individual client organizations, not broader field or economy. Appeal dismissed on first Dhanasar prong.