Published AAO appeal decisions

Civil engineer sought EB-2 exceptional ability classification with national interest waiver. Petitioner claimed two additional criteria beyond the one (official academic record) the director found met. AAO held petitioner failed to meet three required criteria for exceptional ability and thus did not reach Dhanasar waiver analysis.

A general and operations manager seeks EB-2 NIW as individual of exceptional ability. The petitioner claimed multiple exceptional ability criteria. The AAO dismissed the appeal, finding petitioner did not satisfy three of six criteria required for exceptional ability, eliminating NIW eligibility.

Financial analyst with advanced degree seeking EB-2 classification and national interest waiver. Petitioner proposed real estate financial advisory work but failed to establish national importance under Dhanasar first prong. AAO found proposed endeavor lacks sufficient prospective impact beyond employer and clientele to warrant waiver.

Product manager with doctorate in robotics and AI sought EB-1A extraordinary ability. AAO found three criteria met (awards, scholarly articles, leading role) but final merits analysis showed achievements insufficient for sustained national/international acclaim at top of field level.

A sports management company petitioned for a sumo wrestler seeking O-1A extraordinary ability. The applicant met only the awards criterion. Claims of membership in elite associations and published media coverage failed because the federation membership lacked documented outstanding achievement requirements and articles lacked proper attribution. Fewer than three criteria were satisfied so appeal was dismissed.

A petroleum drilling engineer holding advanced-degree equivalent sought an EB-2 national interest waiver. The AAO affirmed denial, finding his proposed endeavor of continuing employment in casing and cementing specialization lacked national importance. Though well positioned to advance the work, failure on the first prong precluded waiver eligibility.

Electrical engineering researcher employed in semiconductor development sought NIW for EB-2 classification. Petitioner claimed three Dhanasar prongs. AAO sustained appeal, finding proposed next-generation semiconductor research has national importance, petitioner is well-positioned to advance it, and waiver benefits U.S. interests.

A marketing professional with tourism and hotel management degree sought an EB-2 national interest waiver to start and manage her own tourism business. The AAO affirmed denial, finding her proposed endeavor lacked national importance because it would serve only specific clients without broader economic impact, and she was not well positioned to advance it.

An engineering company sponsored a thermofluidic and bridge erosion researcher for O-1A extraordinary ability. The petitioner submitted evidence for four criteria but satisfied only scholarly articles. The AAO found the beneficiary's published work lacked demonstration of major significance; diverse skillset alone does not constitute original contributions of requisite magnitude. Appeal dismissed.

English language and literature teacher sought EB-2 with national interest waiver. Claimed advanced degree professional or exceptional ability status. AAO held petitioner did not meet EB-2 eligibility requirements; foreign degree unrelated to proposed endeavor; did not satisfy three of six exceptional ability criteria; Dhanasar analysis reserved.

Business development director sought EB-2 NIW as advanced degree professional. Qualified for underlying EB-2. AAO found proposed business development endeavor poorly defined and lacking substantial merit and national importance. Petitioner failed to document specific projects, scale, or prospective economic impact needed to establish national importance.

Employer petitioned for basketball player for O-1A classification. Petition failed on contract documentation, event description, and evidentiary criteria requirements. AAO dismissed appeal because petitioner waived contest of contract and event grounds and AAO declined to reach the evidentiary criterion argument.

A martial arts academy sought O-1A extension for an MMA athletic trainer. The AAO remanded, finding the director erred in concluding the RFE response lacked supporting documentation; FedEx tracking and copies of submitted exhibits proved delivery of a three-pound package, warranting reconsideration of substantive eligibility criteria.

Electrical engineer seeking EB-2 with national interest waiver. AAO affirmed denial because petitioner failed to establish EB-2 eligibility and, independently, failed the first Dhanasar prong by not demonstrating his specific proposed endeavor has national importance.

Mechatronics engineer sought EB-2 with national interest waiver. Described endeavor as continued employment with multinational companies on cross-border transactions; later added business plan and service company. AAO held proposed endeavor lacked national importance; business plan materials presented new facts post-filing; letters and articles address industry, not specific endeavor impact.

Former military officer seeking EB-2 classification as advanced degree professional or individual of exceptional ability, plus national interest waiver. Petitioner did not hold recognized bachelor's degree equivalent and failed to establish three of six exceptional ability categories. Ineligible for EB-2; appeal dismissed.

Education counseling business petitioned for school and career counselor beneficiary's O-1A classification. Petitioner claimed seven criteria; director and AAO found none met. Letters lacked evidence of major field significance. Salary was average, not elevated. Appeal dismissed without final merits determination.

A finance consultant with advanced degree seeks EB-2 NIW. The petitioner proposed operating a financial consulting company. The AAO dismissed the appeal, finding the endeavor lacks national importance and substantial positive economic effects required under Dhanasar.

A project manager in sustainable construction seeks NIW for solar panel and green building consulting. AAO dismissed appeal because the endeavor, though meritorious, lacks national importance and the petitioner provided inconsistent and vague descriptions of the specific proposed activities.

A pediatrician seeks NIW to open a pediatric medical clinic in Florida. AAO dismissed because the proposed endeavor, though in a meritorious field, lacks national importance; it does not establish prospective impact on pediatric practice broadly or substantial economic effect at the national level.

Professional with 25 years in oil and gas sought NIW for digital transformation and operations manager role. AAO held substantial merit was established but dismissed because proposed endeavor lacked national importance; applicant's career experience could not substitute for demonstrating the specific endeavor's prospective impact and broader implications.

Veterinary sonographer sought NIW under EB-2 with job offer. AAO dismissed the appeal because the proposed endeavor of providing veterinary sonography services lacks national importance; it only benefits individual pet owners rather than impacting the veterinary field broadly or the national economy.

An employer sponsored a radiation oncology physician for EB-1A extraordinary ability. The beneficiary met judging and scholarly articles criteria but failed membership and published material criteria. Original contributions not shown to have major significance. Extraordinary ability sustained acclaim was not established. Appeal dismissed.