Published AAO appeal decisions

Cost estimator seeking NIW for position on EV battery plant projects. Claimed national importance based on EV industry significance and clean energy priorities. AAO dismissed because specific endeavor as cost estimator lacks national importance; industry importance and personal role value insufficient; no evidence of original innovations or broader prospective impact.

A researcher with published work seeks EB-2 with national interest waiver to pursue computer science research and lecturer position applying computer science to business processes. She failed to demonstrate her research has national importance or broader field impact and did not establish she is well-positioned to advance the endeavor. The AAO dismissed the appeal.

Sports management CEO sought EB-2 NIW classification. Petition dismissed for procedural defects: incomplete Form I-140 and failure to submit required DOL Form ETA-9089 Appendix A despite request for evidence. AAO upheld denial without reaching merits of national interest waiver claim.

General and operations manager in paint manufacturing seeks NIW based on proposed consulting and training business. AAO affirmed dismissal, finding proposed endeavor lacks national importance; no evidence of broader implications, significant employment potential, or substantial economic effects beyond individual clients.

Telecommunications entrepreneur with master's degree seeking EB-2 NIW for business providing rural connectivity and mobile network solutions. AAO dismissed appeal; petitioner failed to demonstrate national importance as proposed endeavor lacked evidence of extended field impact or improved methods over existing U.S. practices.

Industrial production manager sought NIW based on exceptional ability. In RFE response, petitioner changed proposed endeavor to operating a company providing wind farm maintenance services. AAO dismissed, finding material change impermissible and initial endeavor lacked national importance.

IT sales manager with advanced degree seeks EB-2 classification with national interest waiver. AAO upheld denial, finding petitioner established substantial merit but failed to show national importance; stated intention to work in important field does not establish national importance of specific proposed endeavor.

Aircraft maintenance technician with advanced degree and exceptional ability seeks national interest waiver to continue working in aircraft maintenance and assembly. AAO dismissed appeal because petitioner failed to establish national importance of the proposed endeavor and waived the issue by not addressing it on appeal.

An industrial engineer sought an EB-2 classification with a national interest waiver, relying on recommendation letters, publication and citation records, industry reports, and the STEM nature of his work. The AAO dismissed the appeal because the evidence did not show the national importance of his specific proposed endeavor, so the other prongs were not analyzed.

HR entrepreneur seeking EB-2 NIW for human resources consulting business. Claimed endeavor advances economy and SME sector through sustainable labor practices. AAO dismissed appeal, finding proposed business lacks national importance; benefits remain limited to direct clients without broader economic implications.

Interior designer and CEO/entrepreneur sought EB-2 NIW. Petitioner claimed three exceptional ability criteria but established only one: advanced degree. AAO found insufficient evidence of ten years full-time experience, professional association membership, and industry recognition. Ineligible for underlying EB-2 classification; NIW analysis reserved.

Business intelligence analyst seeking EB-2 with NIW claimed all three Dhanasar prongs. AAO affirmed underlying advanced degree eligibility but dismissed appeal, finding proposed business endeavor lacks national importance with no demonstrated prospective impact beyond clients.

Industrial engineer seeking NIW for EB-2 classification claims proposed endeavor in supply chain optimization, warehouse operations using AI, and autonomous air taxis addresses national interests. AAO held the endeavor lacks demonstrated national importance; working in STEM and emerging technologies alone insufficient without evidence of prospective impact or broader implications.

A general and operations manager seeks NIW for EB-2 to establish a consulting business for organizational development and business optimization. AAO found substantial merit but no national importance; the generic business plans lacked specific, targeted impact beyond local customers in a large industry.

Industrial engineer seeking EB-2 with national interest waiver for proposed work developing manufacturing solutions for supply chain and healthcare. AAO confirmed advanced degree eligibility but dismissed because proposed endeavor lacks demonstrated national importance; claimed broad impacts were conclusory without supporting evidence.

A commercial airline pilot and captain with advanced qualifications proposed pilot and flight instructor work and aviation safety consultancy. The AAO held his expertise and prior success, while relevant to positioning under the second prong, do not establish national importance of the specific proposed endeavor, which lacks demonstrated broader implications for the aviation industry.

Entrepreneur seeking EB-2 with self-petitioner NIW for cybersecurity and IT consulting startup. Claimed endeavor has national importance through potential employment and economic ripple effects. AAO held endeavor lacks national importance; specific business plan too vague; benefits limited to company and clients; no evidence of broader implications.

A civil engineer with a Master's degree in civil engineering proposed research on recycled materials in asphalt pavement. The AAO held the proposed endeavor, while occurring in a STEM field, lacks substantial national importance because it shows no broader implications commensurate with national interest, failing the first Dhanasar prong.

Self-petitioner, IT professional proposing specialized IT consulting and training business. Claimed national importance based on STEM field work and gender diversity in IT. AAO dismissed, finding the specific endeavor lacks national importance; working in STEM alone does not establish national importance of a particular proposed business.

Trade marketing and ecommerce consultant with MBA sought EB-2 NIW. AAO affirmed dismissal, finding proposed endeavor lacks national importance under Dhanasar framework. Evidence of professional skills and industry reports insufficient; no demonstration of broader impact beyond petitioner's company or customers.

An electrical engineer with an MBA sought EB-2 classification and NIW for a consulting firm offering process safety and sustainable energy services. The proposed endeavor lacks national importance; it does not extend beyond the petitioner's employer and clients to impact the field broadly or employ disadvantaged workers.

Climate economics researcher proposed research on carbon cap-and-trade and green jobs. AAO held the proposed endeavor lacks national importance because petitioner failed to show how specific research would impact U.S. policy or economy; relying on field importance and past accomplishments insufficient.

An administrative and human resources manager seeking EB-2 with NIW to establish a management consulting firm claimed substantial merit and national importance. The AAO found the endeavor lacked national importance, having only limited benefits to prospective clients and employees without broader economic implications.

ENT physician with advanced degree seeking NIW for EB-2. AAO found first two Dhanasar prongs met: proposed medical endeavor has national importance and petitioner well-positioned. Failed third prong: insufficient urgency to waive labor certification requirement.

Advanced degree professional seeks EB-2 classification with national interest waiver for business development endeavor. AAO dismissed appeal, finding proposed work extending to business associations lacks demonstrated national or global implications, does not directly employ workers, and fails to show significant positive economic effects indicative of national importance.